Let’s cut to the chase: you’re not running a tech startup because you’re a genius at prompt engineering. You’re an entrepreneur because you’ve got instincts—gut feelings honed by experience, hustle, and a knack for spotting opportunities others miss. But here’s the rub: if you’re leaning on GPTs like they’re your business’s brain, you’re dulling those instincts faster than a bad hire drains your budget. AI tools, like the custom GPTs you can build or access on platforms like grok.com or OpenAI’s GPT Store, are powerful. They can analyze data, draft emails, and spit out ideas in seconds. But they’re not your CEO, and treating them like one is a one-way ticket to mediocrity.

Entrepreneurs thrive on sharp decision-making, not blind trust in algorithms. Yet, I see it all the time: founders asking their GPTs for answers like they’re consulting a magic eight-ball, accepting outputs without a second thought. That’s not leveraging AI—that’s outsourcing your brain. And it’s killing your ability to think critically, adapt on the fly, and make the bold calls that define great businesses. Here’s why over-reliance on GPTs is a trap, and how to use them to sharpen your instincts instead of dulling them.

The Trap of the Yes-Man GPT

GPTs are designed to please. Feed them a prompt, and they’ll churn out responses tailored to your request, often with a side of flattery. Ask, “Is my business idea good?” and you’ll get a polished essay on why you’re practically Elon Musk. That feels great—until you realize it’s just regurgitating your optimism back at you. This is the yes-man problem. Real growth comes from friction, from being challenged, not coddled. If you’re nodding along to every GPT output, you’re not innovating—you’re coasting.

I’ve worked with entrepreneurs who’ve fallen into this trap. One founder, let’s call her Sarah, built a custom GPT to brainstorm marketing strategies for her e-commerce startup. She loved how it churned out catchy taglines and campaign ideas. But when sales flatlined, she was stumped. Why? Her GPT wasn’t programmed to question her assumptions or point out that her target market was saturated. She was so busy high-fiving her AI that she missed the red flags a human mentor would’ve spotted in a heartbeat.

Why (Still) Instincts Matter More Than AI

Your business instincts are your edge. They’re what tell you to pivot when a product launch flops or to double down when a risky bet starts paying off. GPTs don’t have that. They’re pattern-matchers, pulling from data and prompts, not intuition born of real-world grit. Over-rely on them, and you start second-guessing yourself. You hesitate on decisions, waiting for the AI’s “approval.” That’s not leadership—it’s paralysis.

A study from Harvard Business Review in 2024 noted that leaders who overly depend on AI for decision-making report a 20% drop in confidence in their own judgment over time. That’s not just a stat—it’s a warning. Your instincts are like a muscle: use them or lose them. If you’re outsourcing every big call to a GPT, you’re not just stunting your growth—you’re risking your business’s soul.

How to Use GPTs to Sharpen Your Edge

Here’s the good news: GPTs can make you sharper, not softer, if you use them right. The trick is to treat them as a sparring partner, not a sage. Here’s how to do it.

  1. Build a Contrarian GPT: Create a custom GPT with instructions to challenge your ideas. For example, prompt it with: “Act as a skeptical investor. Review my business plan and list three reasons it might fail. Back each reason with data or logic.” Run your strategies through this GPT weekly. It’ll force you to confront weaknesses you’d rather ignore, like a mentor who doesn’t care about your feelings.

  2. Demand Alternatives: Don’t settle for the first answer. Instruct your GPT to provide multiple perspectives. For instance, “Give me three different pricing strategies for my product, including one I likely haven’t considered. Explain the risks of each.” This pushes you to weigh options critically, not just pick the shiniest one.

  3. Test Outputs Against Reality: GPTs love to sound confident, but they’re not infallible. If your GPT suggests a marketing tactic, test it small-scale before going all-in. For example, if it recommends a social media ad campaign, run a $100 test on X and measure results. Data trumps AI every time.

  4. Limit AI for Big Decisions: Use GPTs for research and analysis, not final calls. Let’s say you’re deciding whether to expand into a new market. Ask your GPT to summarize market trends and risks, but make the go/no-go decision yourself, factoring in your instincts and experience.

A Real-World Example

Let’s focus for a second on Silvio, an entrepreneur who runs a SaaS company. He was ready to launch a new feature based on glowing GPT-generated customer personas. But instead of diving in, he built a custom GPT to act as a “devil’s advocate,” prompting it to: “Analyze my feature idea and identify three ways it could alienate my core users.” The GPT flagged that the feature was too complex for his budget-conscious customers—a blind spot Silvio hadn’t seen. He pivoted to a simpler version, saving six figures in development costs and boosting retention by 15%. The GPT didn’t make the call; Mike’s instincts, sharpened by AI’s pushback, did.

Consider a Few Actionable Steps

Here’s your playbook to stop cuddling your GPT and start using it like a pro:

  • Step 1: Build a custom GPT and set its instructions to prioritize critical feedback over affirmation. Sample prompt: “Always challenge my assumptions and provide evidence-based counterarguments.”

  • Step 2: Run every major business idea through this GPT. Ask for risks, flaws, and alternative approaches. Document its feedback in a decision log.

  • Step 3: Test GPT suggestions in the real world with small experiments. For example, if it suggests a new sales funnel, pilot it with 10% of your leads before scaling.

  • Step 4: Schedule a monthly “instinct check.” Review decisions you’ve made with and without AI. Are you leaning on the GPT too much? If so, dial it back.

The Bottom Line

AI amplifies your instincts, not replaces them. A GPT is a tool, not your boss. By designing it to challenge you, question your plans, and force you to think harder, you’re not just building a better business—you’re building a better you. Stop treating your GPT like a cozy blanket and start treating it like a sparring partner. Your instincts will thank you, and so will your bottom line.

For more, visit the official BrainstormGPTs resource center.

Keep Reading

No posts found